View Tangible IP's latest IP Market Updates. Read by over 12,000 professionals in the IP, business, and investment community.
View this email in your browser

IP Market Updates

September 5, 2017

The last weeks of August are normally fairly quiet when it comes to the intellectual property world and marketplace. This year was not the case, with several major announcements that I will review and discuss below. But before I do, we recently released to the market a few very intriguing patent portfolios around technologies such as self-driving and collision avoidance, automotive telematics, mobile payments, etc. that are already attracting interest from buyers. You can review those and others here and write me if you would like to receive more details.
After months of suspense and drama like only the Trump Whitehouse can seemingly create, we finally have an official nomination for a new UPSTO director, Mr. Andrei Iancu, in replacement of the controversial Michelle Lee who resigned, un-resigned and finally resigned again from her post a few months ago. The nominee, should he be confirmed by the US Senate (which is expected), is largely viewed as a very competent patent litigator familiar with the ins and outs of the system. However, he remains largely an unknown quantity when it comes to his views surrounding the current patent system.  He represented patent owner TiVo in court against some of the largest tech companies (Microsoft, Cisco, Verizon, etc.), but also sided with a defendant in a landmark biotech case that has left the life science industry reeling about the damages done to the patent system. He has no direct industry background and has not written on policy. Being mainly a litigator for most of his career, his loyalties have been to his clients and he has maintained a fairly low public profile perhaps saving himself the embarrassment of having to explain away some past inconsistent statements. This leaves us, as with many US agencies, with a new director who comes to the job not only with a clean slate, but also as a blank canvas. This makes any predictions quite risky.  If and once confirmed, he will have to tackle with matters such as patent quality, the constitutionality of  IPRs, fee diversion and accusations laid against its own PTAB for abuse of discretion (by the Federal Circuit) and anti-patent bias (by pretty much everyone in the community). Incidentally and apparently unfazed by such widening criticism, that very PTAB was so brazen as to recently admitting to “stacking” its panel of judges to conform with its views! Let’s hope the new director will retake control of what looks increasingly like a runaway train.

On the transaction side, we heard that Finnish giant Nokia recently transferred 6000 of its own patents to AWA licensing, which will now be tasked to monetize this large portfolio, and publicly traded NPE Finjan bought a discrete group (about 40) of cyber security patents from IBM that will complement its aging portfolio in the same area. Finjan is one of the few NPEs that has been relatively successful enforcing its patents recently. Finally, Chinese Huawei bought a small group of patents from Hitachi, which is somewhat newsworthy since the two behemoths are currently engaged in a patent war. 

Meanwhile and a bit lost in the background was a massive transaction involving the sale of IP service provider CPA Global, a powerhouse in the IP community, for a whopping $3.1 billion dollars, just 5 years after an original purchase price of slightly over $1 billion. The new owner is US based PE firm Leonard Green & Partners. 
On the Who’s Who list, we saw a couple of interesting moves with Google’s Chief IP Counsel Allen Lo leaving to take a similar position with Facebook (replacing Sam O’Rourke), while John Lindgren, the former CEO of large Canadian based NPE Conversant (formerly MOSAID), took on a similar role with another privately owned (by Vector Capital) NPE, IPValue, after a discrete executive search that went on for many months. IPValue’s departing CEO and veteran (since 2002) Murali Dharan, will remain on the board. Finally, well-known figure Brian Hinman will step down after 4 years as Phillips’ Chief IP Officer.
I often contrast the situation between the US and China as it has offered a textbook lesson over the past year as to what to do (and not to do) if you want to improve IP rights and, as a result, attract new investments.

It is well accepted that China has made great strides in building a patent system that many pundits now saying it does a better job than the one in the US of protecting patent owners. With this context in mind, it was quite interesting to learn that President Trump authorized US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer to initiate a Section 301 investigation on August 15th to review China’s practices in regard to intellectual property and US-based companies. Although many of the claims laid against China are not new and many have been well documented over the years, the Trump Administration has a credibility problem on this front and it did not take long for China to call that kettle black, pointing to the poor job the US has done in recent years at protecting its own IP. Maybe this is what was needed to give Congress a good wakeup call that things are not as they used to be. This will be interesting to follow. In the meantime, China has become very agile at playing the system both ways; on one hand, it has built a robust patent enforcement system that tends to favors all patent owners (not just Chinese companies). On the other hand, it has taken a page off the US old book and is starting to support antitrust arguments raised by Chinese companies when fighting large entrenched multinational tech companies. We saw this in China with Qualcomm and – more recently with Apple. And Chinese companies have apparently become comfortable enough to bring their fight onto US territory: last week we saw Chinese appliance maker Haier file an antitrust lawsuit in the Northern District of New York against MPEG LA and the licensors that are part of its ATSC patent pool, namely Phillips, LG Electronics, Panasonic, Samsung Electronics, Columbia University and Zenith Electronics (an LG subsidiary).

I have been writing for years about the long-term consequences of inflicting damage to the US patent system while China, Europe and some emerging countries were doing exactly the opposite; we are starting to see how this plays out on a global scale and the margin for error has become very thin for the US to get its act together before it is too late on this front.

Other news and recently announced deals below…



 A better US patent system will spur innovation 
Financial Times 
But if you are a researcher in the US, you may very well not get a patent for your game changing discovery, because recent shifts in the system mean (more ...)

 Justices Told AIA Reviews Cripple Patents, Harm Innovation 
Law360, New York (September 1, 2017, 8:46 PM EDT) -- Dozens of inventors, patent owners, life sciences companies and conservative groups urged (more ...)

 Stronger Patents Act: 5 Significant Proposed Changes to Inter Partes Reviews 
JD Supra
Recently, Senator Christopher Coons (D-Del) introduced the STRONGER Patents Act of 2017. So far, this is the only legislation introduced in this (more ...)

 China and intellectual property: Patents and Trumpism finally intersect 
American Enterprise Institute 
“Tariffs!” President Trump reportedly thundered at his aides earlier this year in the Oval Office. “I want tariffs. And what do they do? They bring me IP.  (more ...)

 Finjan (FNJN) Buys IBM Cybersecurity Patents to Monetize 
Zacks Small Cap Research

Finjan announced that its new wholly owned subsidiary, Finjan Blue (NASDAQ:FNJN), entered into a patent assignment and support agreement with (more ...)

 CPA Global sold for £2.4 billion 
IPPro Patents 
CPA Global was recently granted a contract with the US Patent and Trademark Office, allowing it to provide full classification services to support the (more ...)

 Nokia Offloading Over 6000 Patents Related to 4G, 5G, SDN, VR, and More 
Wireless Week 
Telecom equipment giant Nokia is offloading more than 6,000 patents related to 4G, 5G, SDN, VR, and more in the wake of its recent merger deal with (more ...)

 Patent reform is critical to protecting American inventors 
The Hill
Throughout American history, patents have been key to making the United States the world's leader in innovation. They have spurred the development (more ...)

 IP lawyer who represented TiVo is Trump's pick as USPTO chief 
Ars Technica 
President Donald Trump has selected Andrei Iancu, the managing partner of a major Los Angeles law firm, to be the next head of the US Patent and (more ...)

 IP Strategy is a Tricky Balancing Act for Pharmaceuticals 
The 20 years of protection afforded by a patent is intended to promote innovation by allowing inventors a chance to recoup development costs and (more ...)

 Trade Secrets v Patents: trade secrets increasingly used to protect innovation
The EUIPO published a study in July 2017 on Protecting Innovation Through Trade Secrets and Patents, based on a survey of around 200,000 (more ...)

 Samsung, LG, Others Hit With Antitrust Suit Over TV Patents 
Haier America Trading LLC, which is claiming violations to the Sherman Act and state law, says that MPEG LA LLC, a patent licensing company that (more ...)

 EIT acquires 22 patents from spine surgeon Dr. Morgan LorioBecker's Orthopedic & Spine 
Emerging Implant Technologies acquired a portfolio of patents from Morgan P. Lorio, MD, of Nashville, Tenn.-based Hughston Clinic Orthopaedics.  (more ...)

 Building a Portfolio in a Depressed Patent Market 
“Eventually Congress will recognize that all the changes enacted to address the overblown patent troll issue has resulted in far more damage to U.S. (more ...)

 The Problem of Patent Valuation 
The anti-patent narrative views patent quality as the major nexus that distinguishes bad patents from good patents. This article has argued that notions (more ...)


Louis Carbonneau, Founder & CEO
IAM World's Leading IP Strategists since 2012

Tangible IP is a strategic IP advisory firm and the global leader in the sale and acquisition of high-quality patents, with a proven track record of over 2000 patents successfully brokered. If you are looking for strategic IP advice or have patents that could be monetized to raise capital or reinvest into your R&D, please contact us at
Recent Events
Mr. Carbonneau attended the annual IP Business Conference in Ottawa, Canada on June 18-20, 2017. 
On April 26, 2017, Mr. Carbonneau was a keynote speaker at the 9th bi-annual edition of FORPIQ conference in Montreal where he talked about Embracing the New IP Reality.  
On May 3, 2017, Mr. Carbonneau spoke at the 2nd Annual Cleantech Summit of Sustainable Development Technology Canada (SDTC) in Ottawa. SDTC is an independent national public entity that funds Canadian cleantech projects and coaches the companies that lead them as they move their ground-breaking technologies to market. Mr. Carbonneau moderated a panel discussing a national IP strategy for the clean tech industry.  
New Patent Sale Completed
Tangible IP recently closed a patent sale in the field of Critical Notification and Information Management Systems. We have closed on 4 new portfolio sales since the beginning of the year and have more transactions in closing. Look for more public announcements shortly.

New Portfolios for Sale
We have several patent portfolios for sale, most of them with detailed evidence of use (EoU). To see all available portfolios, or to submit patents for a free evaluation, visit our website.
Our services are designed to form the building blocks of a complete IP ecosystem, from due diligence to sophisticated strategic advisory, from valuation to complex sales and IP licensing program. Most services can be procured separately or combined to better fit your needs and minimize duplicate costs. In most cases, you will get valuable insights and strategic tools to create and maintain a sustainable competitive advantage for much less than the price of filing a single patent application.
Patent Monetization Services Strategic Advisory Services
Past Newsletters

August 8, 2017
July 17, 2017
June 26, 2017
June 19, 2017
June 6, 2017
May 15, 2017
April 30, 2017
April 24, 2017
April 10, 2017
March 31, 2017
March 23, 2017
February 24, 2017
February 21, 2017
February 3, 2017
December 6, 2016
November 29, 2016
November 22, 2016
November 15, 2016
November 7, 2016
October 27, 2016
October 17, 2016
October 9, 2016
October 3, 2016
August 15, 2016
July 29, 2016
July 11, 2016
July 1, 2016
June 20, 2016
May 31, 2016
May 17, 2016
April 22, 2016
April 11, 2016
March 17, 2016
March 7, 2016
February 29, 2016
February 22, 2016


Copyright © 2011-2017 Tangible IP, LLC, All rights reserved.

Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list

Did you receive this from a friend? You can sign up to receive these emails from us